The Return (2007)

The Return is the product of the complete and utter lack of imagination in the horror genre nowadays.

Quite simply, it takes a variety of elements that are generally considered to be scary, mashes them together any old how, and throws them at the screen without any regard to plot, pacing, sense or coherency. The whole God-forsaken mess is then haphazardly peppered with close-ups of Sarah Michelle Gellar's eyes.

She does have pretty eyes, in fairness, but that doesn't make up for the fact that she couldn't be interesting if her life depended upon it.

What a waste of time.

IMDB link